The Summer I Turned Pretty has taken over timelines and group chats everywhere, but what exactly makes this teen drama such a massive obsession? Find out here
I’ll admit it: I don’t shy away from cutesy shows now and then. Sometimes they’re the perfect escape. But The Summer I Turned Pretty? I’ve been dodging it like a bullet. The trailers and teasers never gave me that must-watch-now pull. Still, with the way this show has taken over the internet, from TikTok edits to endless ‘Team Conrad vs. Team Jeremiah’ debates, I couldn’t help but dig in and try to figure out why it has everyone hooked.
For my teenage cousins, this show is everything. They dissect every scene, send me memes, and are constantly switching sides in the Conrad/Jeremiah debate. But here’s what surprised me – it’s not just teens who are bingeing it. Adults are equally caught up, and it’s not hard to see why.
I think the reason is simple: for teens, it’s an escape into the kind of summer they want to live – the love, the heartbreak, the feeling that everything matters. For adults, it’s nostalgia. It takes you back to a time when life felt dramatic in the smallest ways, when a look or a crush carried the weight of the world. The show hits both audiences right where it hurts (in the best way).
The Conrad vs. Jeremiah Effect
The love triangle isn’t groundbreaking. Belly torn between two brothers could easily feel predictable. But maybe it’s the way it’s done – full of grief, longing, and complicated emotions – has created a fandom that treats these fictional characters like real people. TikTok and Twitter are overflowing with edits, fan wars, and emotional breakdowns about who Belly should end up with.
I’ve seen the debate play out myself. Team Conrad, Team Jeremiah – it’s everywhere. And that’s exactly why the hype hasn’t died down. Fans don’t just watch the show; they interact with it, argue about it, and keep it alive long after the credits roll.
More Than Just Another Teen Drama
Here’s the thing: The Summer I Turned Pretty isn’t reinventing television. It’s familiar, even predictable at times. But what Jenny Han does so well is capture a feeling (By the way, I’m a huge To All The Boys trilogy fan, who prayed for her own Peter Kavinsky!). The golden glow of Cousins Beach, the Taylor Swift soundtrack, the soft sadness tucked inside the story – it all blends together into something that feels like memory.
It’s not really about Belly or which brother she chooses. It’s about reliving the intensity of growing up, that mix of joy and ache that comes with first love and fleeting summers. That’s why people throw themed parties, dress like Cousins Beach characters, and make playlists inspired by the show. It’s not just TV anymore – it’s a cultural mood board.
So yes, I may not have binged it yet, but I get it now. The Summer I Turned Pretty settles into your emotions in a way few shows manage. It’s simple, yes, but it’s also comforting, relatable, and filled with drama. Hey, if you’re like me, you might catch yourself laughing. (I laughed at the debates and trailer as it made me go ‘huh’ big time!)
Having said all that, and yes after doing my fair share of research, I still might not end up watching it. Maybe I’ve grown out of it, maybe it’s just not my cup of tea, or maybe I don’t really vibe with the cast. Or perhaps, I simply have too many of my own issues to resolve than to spend time helping Belly figure out whether Conrad or Jeremiah is the better choice. Either way, the craze around The Summer I Turned Pretty is real – even if I choose to stay on the sidelines watching the hype instead of the show itself.
Sources: Elle, Guardian, Insights Made In China, Northeastern News
Comments 2